In a Zelda rush right now. I just... Damn... I want Zelda U now!
So I've been playing Hyrule Warriors, and alternating my play sessions with a replay of Skyward Sword.
Hyrule Warriors is a solid 7.5. As I said earlier in the thread. Very enjoyable and fun, but lacking just a bit of depth in my book.
Skyward Sword is a 8.5 game to me. It's a very good Zelda game, with some great ideas and competant motion controls. But... To me... It would have been a better game if they tailored the gameplay around regular controls. Since I just never enjoyed motion controls over traditional controls.
I must say the controls are probably as good as motion controls can be for that type of game.. Which should tell a lot.