How in the world are you guys going to decide who was right and who was wrong? MS is being excessively shy with its Xbone sell-through numbers and you're all assuming that VGC's #s are accurate, which many people on gaf are doubting. People on gaf are putting Xbone sell-through numbers at 9m - 9.5m.
Seriously, 11m sell-through for Xbone is bullcrap. No way Xbone is past 10m.