Intrinsic on 20 January 2015
| plip.plop said: I like the breakdown you presented. But I feel that certain categories should hold more weight than others. I don't think emotion should have the same amount of points as Gameplay, or Quality. It should be broken down more, points wise) like a class in School. i.e. Gameplay=Test, whereas Emotion= pop quizzes Value = Homework. How can you truly enjoy a game with broken controls/features, and poor value/presentation, no matter how good/epic the story is? |
Very true, I completely agree with you. What every the category value difference though, the review should clearly state the fore categories and how many points each category is worth. So when talking about a specific category, they can dock points all they want. If gameplay is worth 4 points and emotion is worth 2, the review can make 10 negative points against emotion but will still not be able to take off more than those total 2 allotted points.
