Beyond: 2 Souls. Sure it's got some strange control decisions and I REALLY wish there was a chronological mode for the story especially after I beat it but the story is spectacularly acted and Willem Dafoe had me in tears during certain parts. It's just very engrossing the way it controls and gets you immersed in the characters just like Heavy Rain which was rated much higher (I love Heavy Rain but it's only slightly above Beyond in my opinion).