What's the Most Overrated Game You've Played and Disliked?

[Burek]

sundin13 said:

IkePoR said:

sundin13 said:
Mass Effect 1 and Red Dead Redemption were both massively flawed in my opinion. RDR is certainly not deserving of the praise it gets, and while ME1 isn't as praised as ME2 (for good reason), even the praise it does have is far too much (imo)

Wow RDR is one of my favorite games of all time... my favorite of last gen.  What did you find flawed about it?

I was better able to explain closer to the time I played it...honestly, the whole thing was fairly forgettable.

From what I remember, it was empty, environments were all too similar, the main story was predictable and fairly boring, the gunplay was unremarkable, dead eye made absolutely no sense and did nothing to help the game, all of the collection quests (collect herbs, skin animals etc) were really boring etc.

I'd say its strongest point was that some of the side characters were decently interesting. Otherwise, the gameplay was unremarkable at best and the main story was quite difficult to care about.

I agree with you on RDR, and am surprised many people like it. What killed it for me is about a dozen cattle driving missions, that dragged the ending unnecessary.