Bioshock, I read all the praise when it was released but passed on it because I don't particularly like FPS games (and I didn't have a 360 at that time). I actually came around to playing it a few months before the release of Bioshock Infinite and Bioshock isn't just good "for an FPS" it's fucking awesome end of sentence. I even made an outdated review for it: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=156819
Signature goes here!