For me, it's gotta be Killzone 3. Lord knows I tried to like this game but after one stage where I got to drive a mercy, I just accepted that it was simply a bland expertise with characters I didn't care about and no moments that got my adrenaline pumping. I even loaned it to an FPS loving friend who promptly have it back. It was the last time I actually traded in a game.
I admit the Move support was good and almost salvaged the experience but it just wasn't enough.








