I haven't watched, but your list of their complaints seems extremely valid. The amount of salt and butt hurt in the GAF thread is mind blowing. Some even claiming there is some mass media conspiracy against Sony LOL.
The more they show of this game tthe more it appears as if it's the PS4 version of Ryse. 3rd person, repetitive combat, very linear, little to no exploration, QTE's, etc, but also just amazing graphics.