By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
outlawauron said:
DeadNotSleeping said:
outlawauron said:

Wanted to her away from developing a game she's unqualified to do =/= silencing her. Her soapbox is unaffected by this PR stunt.

As a critic, she is qualified to be a consultant.  One doesn't have to be an artist to be an effective art critic.  Did you even read my post?

I disagree, largely because I don't think you can really consider her video games series much of a critique. What I was replying to was the silencing comment, which you sidestepped completely.

Edit: Also, if you would like to go that route, you need credibility in order for your critiques to mean anything. She has no credibility with this area.

You only need an opinion, the ability to articulate it, and an audience to have credibility as a critic.  If she lacked any one of the three, she wouldn't have even been noticed.  Evidently, she has all the credibility she needs in this area for the people qualified to manage a video game development studio to hire her for her opinions.