Sonic Boom is already a legend. I don't know if anything can compete with it. Wait, it's already in officially? Okay then...
1. The Crew was the most broken game at release of any game this year, so it does deserve a nomination.
2. Master Chief Collection was a fiasco. It'll be okay in the end, but for the disaster its launch is to the brand, I nominate it.
3. Uh...Thief, that was this year right? That was shit.
I can't think of anything else. Can I just nominate Ubisoft? They're pretty much the shittiest game company out there now. Broken releases, unreasonable review embargoes, the shit they pulled with Watch Dogs Wii U, and that's just this year. Their shit has been going on for a while now and they're showing no signs of improving. They seriously make EA look good. We should have TOTY for companies. Just exclude the 1st party companies, and it should be fine.