What's the best/scariest gaming Creepypasta?

[I3LuEI3omI3eR]

the_dengle said:

Slarvax said:

the_dengle said:
Two people in this thread never completed the Ben Drowned storyline and saw him become a Super Saiyan 3.

Ben drowned is 2spooky4me :S

Actually, I just think is too bizarre. The story is very well made, except for the "why" and "how".

The whole thing is stupid but the ending is godlike.

Why do people get scared watching someone play a modded version of an old game? I just get bored.

Ben drowned is my one of my favorite creepypastas. It's kind of like "we know it's fake, but if any creepypasta were to be real... it would be like this".

I love the whole Lavender Town Syndrome creepy pasta though... I'm glad I learned about it at an older age because I wouldn't be able to sleep for months as a kid hearing this song stuck in my head...