Nice thread.
Story: Hands down God of War 1, 2, Chains of Olympus. A dark twisted take on Greek mythology with an anti-hero main character, Really well made. Although DmC's story was a lot better than previous games, a lot of it was predictable, that scene were Kratos murders his family was a complete shock to me,
Gameplay: Devil May Cry, no contest.
Level design: Pretty much even. Quality wise both have unique aesthetic. DmC edges out the previous games because of the Limbo world, but about even with the sheer quality of God of War's evironments.








