good thread. good responses. I think it works both ways. Sure you dont want to put someone who hates a certain type of game on that genre. But sometimes you have to broaden peoples horizons. If the guy would've enjoyed this game then would we be complaining he didn't like the genre? He could have pointed out things that impressed him that others that are fans of the genre might have taken for granted (oh well GTA does this aiming better so this games stupid). Obviously the main editor or whoever lead the site should've went through and reviewed this review. I don't its fair to say only fans of specific genres can review those genre games but obviously some people are not capable of appreciating certain things. Which is why you have certain checks and balances to ensure your giving out quality reviews.
I do however think the review industry as a whole needs to be redone. I think things are pretty bad in their current state.
EVERY GAMERS WORST NIGHTMARE...THE TANGLING CABLES MONSTER!
Coffee is for closers!
