Skyrim Legendary Edition -- 8.9 -- $19
The game is awfully repetitive but there is so much to explore that it just kind of steals away your time. The sheer amount of content is why I give it a high score. That, and I've spent hours looking through mods.
Edna & Harvey: Harvey's New Eyes -- 7.5 -- like $5 or something on sale, I dunno exactly.
Entertaining and quirky point-&-click puzzle game. Really dark sense of humor. Kind of got tired of loading screens.
Crap. I just realized that I've been living off of PS+ for so long that I've forgotten what I bought before that. Wow.