| Intrinsic said: And yeah I know most agree that reviews from mainline publications are generally untrustworthy, but I am just talking about how best to review games. |
I was actually going to make a thread when seeing the content in the reviews about Drive Club's below average score, but I thought of this thread thought I would post it here. I've already explained my opinion in several threads about howreviews are mostly based on what they think the public wants to see and gaming journalists prove once again that they have little to no integrity at what they do(which I'll point out later in this post.)
Drive Club is a victim of anti hype. The game has been bashed since its announcement by the majority of the internet. A lot of gaming journalists are just giving the public what they want to see. It's the major problem with reviews. Drive Club has so many reviews out there comparing it to the open world of Forza Horizon 2. A lot of these same reviewers gave 9/10 or 10/10 to Forza 5. These reviews then compare the paltry list of vehicles and the inability to customize vehincles, but they fail to counter compare the 55 track variations to the 16 that Forza 5 has. There's actually journalists who did give poor scores to Forza 5 for being an incomplete package, but too many of them gave the game glowing review scores and then nitpicking on another game for not pushing the genre.
Gamespot even bitches that there's no rewind button. The journalist might as well have said "Like many of us corporate journalists do, I suck balls at video games, and because I can't rewind the game whenever I fuck up(which I'm sure is quite often,) I'm going to cry myself to sleep as soon as I post this 5/10 review score. Only after I bitch that it's a standard racing game when the genre has advanced in scope to providing open world experiences." Doesn't stop Gamespot,from giving a 9/10 to Forza 5 which not only didn't provide an open world experience like games prior to it did, games like NFS Most Wanted, Test Drive Unlimited, Test Drive Unlimited 2, Burnout Paradise, etc, but as I mentioned above, it had its own issues, like only having 16 tracks and getting anything decent to drive required an assload of credits.
It doesn't matter what game it is and how hypocritical their comments are, these shitty journalists will always focus on their own agenda. Usually giving scores based on what the public wants to see.
Even though no one has had any experience from The Order 1866 except for that same five minute demo, regardless how good it turns out to be, I guarantee it gets shit on by journalist. Guaranteed to get below an 80. I think it'll get mid 70s at max. No green. Yellow or worse.
