By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Kudistos Megistos said:
VXIII said:

Follow the case to its very first historical origin. Whose land was taken, and then given to others.


Oh damn it, my mistake.

So the Israelis should expel the Romans? But they were already expelled in the east by the Arabs.

Did the Arabs inherit the responsibility to be expelled when they expelled the Romans?

Or perhaps, to make everything fair, we should revive the eastern Roman empire (I'm sure the Turks won't miss IstanbulConstantinople), then the Romans can take back the whole of the Levant, then the Jews can take Israel back from the Romans? Is that how this works?

Israel is a modern term. Your are talking about the history of Jews in general. Jewish populations were a part within different countries and empires, they had no land of their own. Palestine , however is a country by the modern definition. Btw, I'm talking about the right of people in a land, not their politicals leaders, they change all the time.

And yes, if they had a land that was stolen from them, it is their right to get it back.