Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

[impertinence]

WhiteEaglePL said:

impertinence said:
Why the votes on padib? that makes the least sense, we have to either flip wright to test padib vs wright or if we assume wright is telling the truth the vote goes to spurge. Voting padib doesn't make much sense to me.

Because IF both prof and wright are telling the truth, town will kill a Wrigt., and Padib will kill Prof.

 

Both of which IF true, can see invisble units.However, Wright could be the one lying and Padib is telling the truth.

Yes, the way I see it (or saw it at least):

Wright lies and he is the nuke

Padib lies means Spurge is the nuke

This was until the whole snafu of the EMP being assumed to be a ghost attack. Apparently it's more likely that it's a scan and Carl has pointed both padib and the rest of us down the wrong path with not giving the possible alternate explanation of the EMP. Which again means that both padib and wirght could be telling the truth and the nuke could be anyone that is not scanned or otherwise reasonably accounted for.

I have been thinking (before the dust up yesterday) that it would make sense that we have a town scanner (wright) a zerg scanner (prof) and a protoss scanner (unclaimed). This would give all three factions the ability to scan and would let us have enough scans that we could find the nuker by simple process of eliminatiuon if all three factions could succesfully work together.

One thing that doesn't make any sense is for the nuke to attack people at night, even of the nuke has night actions it would be stupid to risk being caught when all he needs to do is sit tight for five Days and not draw attention to himself.