Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

[TruckOSaurus]

theprof00 said:

TruckOSaurus said:

I for one am upset of what your increased activity has brought. You went on pointless arguments with impertinence and padib. You're all over the place, you're needlessly condescending, you refuse to claim your unit or character, you're a major disruption for the Town.  

If you're Town (and that's a big IF at this point), you're playing awfully.

Don't think for a second that you're not one of my suspects trucks.
Padib, for the umpteenth time, is a confirmed third party who wins even if town loses. He is NOT town. You're mad that I'm arguing with a scum!? Seriously?

Impertinence and my discussion started fine. He doubted my role and the counterclaim and that's fine. I've written this several times now. He made claims that I saw as a slip, which was saying that Dark templars were vanilla scum. I then said he was suspicious and accused him of putting up arguments that were unfounded logically. I said "you accuse me of not having a name, but you have no reason to make that assumption. The information we have from players says that some power roles have names and some do not. He claimed that he was being logical. I countered that it was not, and went step by step to prove him wrong, using logical rules. He undermined me the whole time and then finally in the end admitted that he had a hidden axiom which he assumed for the sake of deduction; he left out people he considered to not be power roles, because they were modifiers. I countered again and said that commuter is not a modifier. His response was to come back, and say town was doing fine until I showed up (basically).

Do you have any more to add to your wild accusations?

I have nothing to hide so I don't give a damn if you suspect me. If you weren't so self-centered you'd have noticed that I spent a good chunk of the early Day questioning padib, but I did it in a constructive manner to get as much information as possible, you only push his buttons and you two end up bickering it gets old pretty fast and it isn't productive.

Your whole debate with impertinence was a battle over semantics and it was pointless.

You want me to add to my accussations? Fine.

You claimed a fake power "Smack Down" only to track back on it and rename it "Slap" because you were scared of your real power would look Zerg. First of all, neither of your powers makes sense as a way to detect people using cloaking devices. Second, why would "Slap" sound like a Zerg power? Zergs don't slap. Third, "Slap" doesn't fit in the StarCraft universe.

You refuse to give out your name because "you wanted a challenge". That doesn't fit with the guy who didn't want to claim his real power because he was scared it looked Zerg. If you wanted a challenge claiming a power that sounds Zerg sound be part of that, no? Also, not giving out your name after the claim is just you withholding useful information from the Town for no good reason, it's not a townie thing to do.