PS3 vs 360 in 2008

[makingmusic476]

Legend11 said:

makingmusic476 said:

Legend11 said:

makingmusic476 said:

Ajax said:
thanks for the lists


but the 360's got a much more extensive exclusive list then i thought
doesn't look bad at all

Except for the fact that over 30+ of the games can be bought on PC?

So what's your point? Not everyone has a gaming PC and some people might just want a console instead. There are many console games that won't be on PC and it's kind of ridiculous to say "Well buy a PS3 AND a PC" when they might only want to spend under $400 to begin with.

You still can't just exclude a platform. Should a guy that owns only a Wii and a 40gb ps3 say "Well, Bully is Wii exclusive to ME, because I don't own a 360"?

We're talking about lineups and the lineup for the 360 includes every game being released on that system in 2008. As soon as you start eliminating games on a system because you don't feel they should count you change what the actual lineup of that system is. When comparing the 360's lineup to the PS3's it doesn't matter if a 360 console exclusive also appears on PC because it doesnt change the fact that the game won't be on the PS3. The kind of comparison you want is a 360 vs (PS3 + PC) which isn't what the topic of this thread is about.

Look above at the part I bolded.  The topic may have been about the line up in general, but this particular conversation was about EXCLUSIVES.