spurgeonryan said:
impertinence said:
spurgeonryan said:
To me they are both scum. Scum and the nuker. So yes, we are searching, you answered your own question just now.
@ impertinence
Waht if you were forced to claim right now. You could lie though. Would you say you were a king hero who could do anything? Or would you say vanilla townie? It is a safe claim for both scum and town. Check old games. It is nothing new. What is worrisome is that he has not really been here to say anything, but we have a handful of those types this game. Radish happily came in and said something.
|
so would I claim like padib or like sparks? My thinking is that vanilla town is the safest of all claims and would not be a good town tell. I am not sure scum would lways have the skill to fake claim a power role. See Astro for example, he claimed vanilla town and pretty much disappered. Just like Sparks in other words.
|
Well Padib claimed because he has something up his sleeve. White and Khan claimed partially because it is either a safe thing to say or they really are what they say they are, even though they did not say much.
But ifyou were the doctor and were forced to claim, would you say you were the doctor or vanilla town? Once I lied even though I was town and I believe it was truck who slammed me for lying. I was lynched, they found out I was town, and I was an idiot.
If you say you are the doctor, then scum will go after you. Doctor is a big role. Vanilla town is a universal claim.
|
Yes, so, as I am saying: When Sparks claim vanilla town that is not necessarily a town tell like Radish said, it could be the simples available fake claim. I know it is also possible Sparks is exactly what he claims. I am just saying that Radish assuming he is town because as scum he would not fake claime vanilla town is making a mistake.
For someone who was so hell bent on avoiding useless back and forth about meaningless details at the begining of the game, it's pretty peculiar why you keep this train of discussion going.
Essay Pro