So it looks like GOTY will be going to either DA:I, Bayonetta 2 or LBP3

[GTAexpert]

vkaraujo said:

Bayo > GoW, both gameplaywise AND storywise.

Kratos has a dull personality and is extremely predictable. He hates, thats it.
It was fun the first time, but after that he just bored me.

@OP
For me:
-SMB U
-Child of Light
-DA:I
-Bayo 2
-Dark Souls 2

Safe bet:
-Not a Nintendo game
-Can't have a high difficulty curve (Good bye Dark Souls 2)
-Can't be japanese (Bayo 2 is out)
-Can't be a PC exclusive (Good bye Divinity)
-Can't be a sports or driving game (See you later MK8, DriveClub, Forza)
-Can't be a handheld or mobile game (Sorry Pokemon, Bravely Default))
-Can't be a iterative sequel (Unity/Far Cry 4 out)
-Can't be a Indie (Good bye to some of the best games of the year)
- 90+ Meta Score

So, this year we won't have a GOTY at all it seems

GOW >> Bayonetta, both storywise and gameplaywise.

GOW has a great narrative, variety in combat, epic sense of scale, intense atmosphere, great enemy designs and amazing boss fights. Bayonetta doesn't even come close. Heck, even Platinum's own Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance is better than Bayonetta.