So it looks like GOTY will be going to either DA:I, Bayonetta 2 or LBP3

[poklane]

baloofarsan said:

If you go by Metacritic, and remove remakes/remasters it seems to be the year of indies: 

• Guacamelee! Super Turbo Championship Edition - 90
• Shovel Knight - 92
• Velocity 2X - 90
• ZEN Pinball 2: The Walking Dead - 86
• Resogun -86

Guacamelee is also a remake/remaster, and Resogun is 2013.