Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

[Nicklesbe]

Sparks said:

Nicklesbe said:
So you assume White isn't making an informed descision?*{1} You claim my thoughts on Carl were exaclty like my thoughts on theprof last game when it wasn't. You say my Playstyle this game is the same as last tho it is quite different. The prof finds Carl scummy for very different and logical reasons which you ignore and call him scum that agrees with my points, even tho his reasons are quite different.*{2} Now that one of the biggest suspects and lynch candidates is Astro where the majority of if not all the  people voting for him so far all seem to be quite smart, logical and experianced think he is the best lynch candidate.*{3} Instead of taking them and their reads seriously you would rather dismiss them and try to dogpile on me and discredit anyone that disagrees.*{4} Feels to me like you are trying to save your mafia team mate. TheProf seems to know you and astro very well*{5} and seems to think you are both mafia. Sure maybe he is mafia but then again he could easily be town and has read town for the most part.

1. He admitted himself that he doesn't read everything.
2. On the flip side, he came right to your rescue. He only started posting when you were in trouble, defending you a lot, attacking the people who suspected you.
3. Since when is that a good excuse to vote someone??? You should think for yourself. Also, it's the very definition of bandwagoning.
4. I did take their reads into consideration, and came to the conclusion that you are the better target.
5. Prof doesn't know me at all.

He said he didn't read everything before, it doesn't mean he didn't look at other peoples reads and came to his own conclusion as you claim you are doing. He didn't come to my rescue, he was logical, gave his own reasons for suspecting Carl and said the lynch on me was too easy. Something you continue to ignore. Did you? When? It looks more like you dismissed them completely. So when theprof said he knows you pretty well and trusted you last game that was accurate and ok and a reason for you to trust him and buddy up, but this game now that he suspects you he doesn't know you at all?