By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
XanderXT said:
bigtakilla said:
Jumpin said:

I feel like the only category Xenoblade can reasonably win in is Battle System.

Xenogears hands down for setting, it might have the best setting of any RPG in history. A 10,000 year history which is a reflection of a literal biblical account of earth retold in science fiction terms, and then an additional 4,000 years on the end. It spans back before that too, a creation of Deus/God. Xenosaga a close second given the extraordinary detail they put into the history of technology and the scientists involved.

Characters, it depends, I am going to say not Xenoblade for certain. Xenosaga and Xenogears both have excellent casts and some of the greatest RPG characters ever. Fei tops every RPG main character ever, and KOSMOS is certainly up there. Jin is like a much more interesting version of FFX's Auron. Xenogears has Elly, Miang, Krelian, Citan, and other really strong additional characters. Hard choice.

Environments? I have to admit, Xenoblade probably has this one. Some of the locations like Alcamoth and Frontier Village are breathtaking.


It's his opinion, how can he be wrong? 

It's highlighted. It can not only win in battle system according to you, but environments as well. Therefore it can reasonably win more than just the battle system catagory.