you have some points in there that are good, others come off as a little weak.
while some scum like to put hints in there early posts things that could be shown that they are scum. I don't take early posts day one of day one relating to the flavor as much of anything.
as for your complains of when he is inactive. compared to you this game we're all inactive. but carl has posted more than many players in this game combined. plus he's putting enough time into this game that I won't be complaining about some of his longer gaps.
part of the issue I'm seeing right now is there aren't enough people posting so that you and he don't have much to go off of. With how much you have posted plus twice voting yourself there is plenty to go on you about even if you were town. you're tunneling when you try and say you are 100% sure of someone's alignment.
I am sadly more tired than I thought. So I will have to look more tomorrow. Though when 9 player have less than 80 posts between them. town is in trouble.
