Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

[Nicklesbe]

impertinence said:
EricFabian continuous his evading play. Keeps the vote on WhiteEagle for no reason anyone can come up with, keeps it a secret why he does so, contributes nothing and deflects and defers.

I'd say he is town, he is definitely not able to talk with anybody outside the thread for sure as he would surely have been put in his place by any scum buddies, siblings, lovers or whatever by now. If there is no day talk, I guess it's possible that scum is sitting somewhere ripping their hair out watching this kind of display, but then I'd expect to see more direct attempts by people to make him change his style.

For the most part I kinda agree with this. I don't know if keeping secrets and being evasive is indictive of mafia. Considering last game there were equal amounts of Mafia that were open and forthcoming and Mafia that were overly evasive and secretive. It's basically what gave khan away at the end of the game. I also know that both Sparks and White were evasive and secretive last game. So I think its possible for town to do that, I just feel it is a huge mistake for town to make. Using last game as an example the scretivness and evasivness pretty much lead to sparks getting lynched by mostly town, and most of mafia didn't even vote for him. It made White a huge target as well. Then there was outlaw was not very active andd was also evasive which made it very easy to to make a fake connection between him and the suspicious mafia players. It is suspicious behavior so much so that theprof was convinced that both sparks and outlaw were mafia.

So I think he is worth keeping a close eye on because it is suspicious behavior. However last game 4 people were evasive and secretive and only one of them ended up being mafia. The others however were a huge target and made things very easy for mafia. So I think it is a huge mistake for any town person to act that wat and can be detrimental.

I would not as easily say he is town tho. I also find your last paragraph very strange. Is it possible that you could be his mafia team mate and you are tearing out your hair at his actions and are unable to tell him? So this is how you are subtly trying to tell him?