Starcraft Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

[Nicklesbe]

impertinence said:

The thing that most immideatly stood out to me was Carl's behavior. It's just hard to see how that kind of posting could be ment to help town. of course, it would be superstupid to go out and start dropping scum quotes if he really is scum, this is why i am trying to get a read from you or trucks on how this behavior compares to last game. I think he played, but I don't remember him sticking his neck out like this at all that game. I am looking forward to see what he does tomorrow.

I have no clue what EricFabian is trying to do. Only thing that sort of makes sense would be tgat he wants to make sure whiteeagle's bullshit from the last game doesn't happen again. But is EF experienced enough to connect the harmful behavior from last game to this game? I don't know. It's a peculiar vote. I suspect it might just be a joke, but why white eagle then? I didn't like his explanation of the joke (prof/proof) and in any case don't see how he made the jump to vote for whiteeagle based on that post. 

Radish claim and counterclaim is weird to, but he has played mafia before and doubt he would slip that badly. I'm inclined to think it was a flavor post that perhaps came across as more of a hard claim than intended.

As for you, I seem to recall you saying after the FE game that you would play different next game no matter what team you ended up on. I'm getting town vibes from you, but you are slippery in this game (mafia in general)...

I've never played with carl before. He was a potential replacement in WoW's FE game but never actually played, I believe he just observed. So Trucks will have to answer that one.

I said I wouldn't change my style much if at all. I think last game I had some success because I tried to play as town. I looked for suspicious behavior and tried to ask questions. However I made mistakes and the person I probably had most convinced I was town(padib) suspected me by the end. I doubt there is much if anything I can do to convince anyone I am town this time. Hell I was willing to bet theprof perma ban that I was town when I wasn't, and I bet him a month of sig control which you can see he has until oct 3rd. So anyone that was in or watched last game would be a fool not to suspect me a little. For anyone that hasn't seen it here it is http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=187834&page=1

The only thing I can say that anyone should believe with certainty is that I will try to spot suspicious behavior and try to investigate that behavior. Do with that what you will. If I am killed or lynched in this game it will be revealed that I am town. At that point everyone should take my investigations seriously because I might find mafia. Until then I understand if everyone is cautious of what I say.

I don't know from everyone who all is really experienced and who isn't. Last game the most experienced were our biggest targets which I think were trucks and theprof. We could have killed theprof soon but he successfully made at least me believe he was a bomb. So instead we did everything possible to try and keep him off kilter and agitated like discrediting him, insulting him, confusing him, pointing him in the wrong directions, and even at times overly complimenting him. So I would suggest looking for similar behavior against the most active/accurate investigators and if trucks and theprof are both town then they will likely be in real danger.