theprof00 said:
Here's my recap of what went wrong.
White Eagle - No town support whatsoever, and pretty much lead to the death of the doc and cop
RCT - not a bad job, I knew he was town, but not a good job either
Cone - also not too bad, but spilled the beans day 1, leading a huge power role out for the count since night 1
Sparks - did great, but should have trusted his own scans. Should have trusted himself to take the shot. Should have claimed cop. SHouldn't have claimed swapper. Shouldn't have theorized about the vest thing.
Spurge - you did awesome. Don't kid yourself. If I wasn't alive, mafia would have dominated even more. even with me they were able to convince town to go after everyone else. Last day would have just been white eagle lynched.
Outlaw - non-participant. Made very questionable claims. attacked me constantly for no reason. Looked completely scum to me.
Wright - was actually pretty good aside from getting himself modkilled and trusting khan for virtually no reason.
Trucks - did great as usual, got killed. Not his fault.
Smeags - did great as well. Should have questioned his allegiance to noname a bit more. I wanted to kill noname but figured they were lovers, and I didn't want to lose smeags.
padib - padib basically gave two scum a free pass to dominate the discussion.
It's just really bad luck that outlaw wasn't scum. He easily could have been. I was hot on khan and nickles and noname. It was just a series of unfortunate events, lack of town power supports, and lack of town experience. It really was an all out disaster.
|
I agree with most of this. In particular, outlaw's attacking you on day 4 was his downfall, and the point of no return for town. Calling out your vanilla role was probably what ultimately pinned him as scum for you. I wanted to question your role too, but I realized that whatever it is, it was better for town to leave it a secret. You weren't all that hot on noname though, and I was going to push my team to kill you that night if somehow the game didn't end. Day 2 was bad luck. Day 3 was where everything went wrong, and Sparks made some pretty bad mistakes. I would've lynched him if I were town too. Day 4 could have been a turnaround if outlaw hadn't gone after you. That said, the entire game was somewhat hurt by your alienating padib and outlaw. Padib wouldn't have let us dominate if he hadn't been at odds with you, and outlaw wouldn't have gone after you the last day, and things would have gone better.
