Most FPSs are bad, most devs are clueless.

[SvennoJ]

Different tastes.

Metro 2033: Sneaking through the dark tunnels, great atmosphere.
Resistance 3: Great campaign with a good build up, nicely inspired by HL2.
Dishonered: Very enjoyable, nice world.
Far cry 3: Very good but shot most of its load in the first half, the 2nd island felt like padding.
KZ: SF: Enjoyed the variety in scenery and awesome sound design.
Wolfenstein the new order: Fun game play, felt like walking through a comic book.
I have not played Crysis 3, doesn't interest me, neither do CoD and Battlefield.

Fallout 3 was great too, had a lot of boring filler as well through.
MGS4, good but some of those conversations just went on and on and on and on and on

Modern FPS aren't that bad. They're not gems like HL2 and S.T.A.L.K.E.R, but there is still plenty to enjoy.