Fire Emblem Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

[Nicklesbe]

Sparks said:

1. No, not a planned scheme by mafia. It would have been a subtle scum tell.
2. Speaking for myself, I just gave up on trying to get any useful info from WhiteEagle. But that's also the reason why I don't think he's lying; he's incapable. The 'inconsistencies' to me seemed like confusion over flavor in WoW's PMs.
3. If at any time you saw me tell him anything along the lines of 'everything would be okay', that was me trying to get him comfortable enough to talk, not me actually believing his BS.
4. Khan is more competent than that. I hold him to a higher standard. Looks to me like he doesn't care enough to dig deep, because it would be a waste of his time. Of what use would any leads or investigation be to him? All he and his buddies have to do is choose a kill at night.
5. It was one scenario that fit perfectly with zero contradictions. Some other scenarios: Cone was roleblocked, either Cone or WhiteEagle was lying.
6. No. The idea to shoot Cone arose because of what WhiteEagle said, which directly contradicted Cone's statement about visiting me. Also, choosing to kill Trucks (unknown power) instead of Cone (the frickin doctor) looked pretty suspicious.

1, ok then so what is the reason for the line of questioning then? Also isn't it counter productive to spend so much time jumping from target to target for the gun? Would it not be better to focus on the best suspect we have and then using the new information from the flip then start questioning others?

2.Oh so he is incapable of lying is he? Then how do you explain the fact that he did lie, and admitted he lied? As soon as I revealed my claim he changed his to mirror mine and said he lied about his original claim. So he's obviously not incapable of lying as you claim. Also if he is a such a headache that you won't even bother investgating him why keep him alive? Why not just shoot him? Since he is such a detriment to you that you can't even bother questioning him then he is a detriment to town, and it mkaes me wonder why you want to keep him around. I'm also amazed that after 3 game days of absolutely no activity that you would put more trust in his ramblings then you do in khan. 

4.I hope you can understand how that can be perceived as extremely hypocritical following what you just said in 2. So you are willing to condemn him to death when you just made it clear you care less than him? Lets face it completely ignoring someone because you think they are annoying is terrible for town and shows you don't really care. Also have you considered the fact that Khan is a mod? I know I'm new and maybe I'm wrong but I give the mods some leeway as far as content goes because I know they are busy. have you seen some of the threads lately? All the sexism threads, the kotaku scandal, the MS tax scandal, The Phil fish getting hacked topics on top of the daily console war shit. I figure the mods can get busy. Hell I was banned during night 2 because of one of the sexism threads. I agree tho, he should be questioned, but I don't think his contributions are a reason to condemn him considering he's a mod and especially since you gave a free pass to someone who literally did not contribute for 3 game days that you almost immediately gave up on investigating because you couldn't be bothered.

5. i agree and I honestly don't see how the scenario is changed. The inconsistency is still there, the possibility is still there as far as I can tell. I wasn't convinced by either cone and white. The only thing I can see that's changed is that you and prof gave up on and never really even questioned White and now are pushing khan for no damn good reason. It reeks of bullshit.

6.We still don't know if Cone is doctor or not. As you said yourself the ninja scenario fit. I'm not convinced a roleblock would prevent him from targeting anyone, I'm waiting on a response from WoW now about it.