By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
HylianSwordsman said:
TruckOSaurus said:

I wanted to prove your claim, plain and simple. "Lynching" outlaw provided that, a lot of discussion over whether we should do it or not,  which to me is as good or maybe even better as discussion over the lynching another random townie because in the end we didn't lose a townie (provided Outlaw is town, of course). Also, you're the one who wasted your ability, no one else.

We're supposed to be on a team. Regardless of how bad an idea you think it was, making an effort to eliminate a power that could save us in a LyLo situation is a scummy thing to do. And I don't think we were discussion lynching another random townie, we were discussing lynching someone we had a better case against, thereby increasing our chances of getting a mafia.

There's no great cases on Day One, there's educated guesses at best. Lynching RCT, outlaw, prof, me, you, anyone would have been just that.

I for one am happy of the situation we are in following our choices during Day One, the most probable scenario for a Day One aftermath would have been two dead townies (three if we really have a second killing faction) now instead we have one practically confirmed townie and only one dead townie.



Signature goes here!