Fire Emblem Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

[Mr Khan]

Sparks said:
I'm going to write down a few scenarios, and I want you guys' opinions on the assumptions and conclusions.

It'll be a while, so while I write I want to ask a few questions and reexamine some things, to make sure we're on the same page. I'd really love more than one reply.

1. Do we believe padib is confirmed town? I know nothing can be confirmed, but you know what I mean. Could someone please explain why they think he is? I just want to here someone else's thoughts besides my own.

2. Same thing with outlawauron, but to a lesser degree. We think he's town because of his reaction, but he didn't bother to leave a will like every other person who was about to die (or at least thought they were).

3. Based on the games I looked at, and the number of players in this game (15), I think we have four mafia. However, in narrowing down my suspects, I only consistently get two (MrKhan and Trucks). The good thing about that is I'm almost certain they're scum, Trucks moreso than Khan. The bad news is the others are good at hiding. I do have some "maybes", but that can wait for later. Also, I don't have enough suspects for a multi-factioned game, so there's that.

4. Cone's claim. I want to give my thoughts and here others' ...Towny: 1. He's new and probably wouldn't have thought of such a lie (and make it look like a slip no less) on his own (no daytalk), especially with the risk of counter claim 2. His style seems consistent with his personality, reserved. Scummy: 1. Lack of participation 2. The possibility of a broken combo, though I think this can be mitigated with a strongman and/or roleblocker.

1. Yes, frankly, unless there really is daytalk and he cooked up that scheme with outlaw.

2. So? What does that have to do with anything?

3. I have no bearing on Trucks, being a latecomer to the game. As for myself, i think extended efforts of defense or lack thereof is kind of a "damned if you do, damned if you don't" in this game, so i'm not going to bother and say a bunch of stuff that's just going to be more of a distraction.

4. I think Cone's claim is the best evidence we have of anything gone wrong. Try a lynch, see what comes up. If he is indeed town, his sacrifice will make it all the easier to spot the real mafia based on their reactions or mere process of elimination.