Now for some quick opinions about players:
noname: I like his input so far, I pretty much agree with everything in this post: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6569131
Hylian: To add to what noname said, I found his defense of outlaw to be disproportionate. Particularly in this post http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6565336 where he went as far as counting how many of his last 100 posts were quotes to defend him not starting conversations. I personally don't feel strongly about outlaw being town or Mafia at this point but I really don't look favorably on someone defending another player that strongly. Especially on Day One.
Wright: He's one of two things, either he's disappointed in what the game of Mafia is and he copes by being constantly off-topic and non helpful or he's scum who's acting that way to prevent from having to put forward anything worthwhile.
Cone: I didn't like his early play, somewhat better now but still unknown to me when it comes to alignment.
Mr Khan: When I was reading the thread as a mere bystander he was the first one that gave me a scummy vibe. First of all, he focused on flavor for a long time and most importantly, he jumped on the conegamer voting bandwagon like a lion who's finally found a prey.
Signature goes here!