Fire Emblem Mafia - Game Thread - Concluded

[theprof00]

Nicklesbe said:

Sparks said:
Would people who currently have their vote on prof with no good reason please remove it. You might not have a chance later since there's maybe 2 and a half IRL days left until nightfall.

Even if you think he's scum, he's still doing more good for town than actual town. That alone is good enough a reason for town to want to keep him.

If you are voting prof, I want to hear your reasons in detail.

About smeags and HileanSwordsman. I agree smeags does seem calculated and very statistics oriented. I think that might just be more his personality but then I have no idea if that's normal for him or not. Hylean seems emotional, especially in his talks with prof. Which I can relate to especially as a new player. I give credit to prof for being able to push people's buttons tho. I don't see how he is doing more good for town. Yeah he talks the most but look at the posts most people clam up around him now, I wonder why that is. That and throwing around baseless accusation just muddies the water. I agree with Padib that ya should hang onto the information and let it build. Also to let everyone relax so they open up more. Then once you find something that's solid then ya go into it. Which is what I tried to do. 

I wasn't aware that it was even possible to remove a vote once it's been cast. I don't agree with Khan's vote, at least his stated reason for it. It's good reason to suspect him but it alone isn't enough to vote him.I understan RCT's vote, prof lied and called him a noob when he knew well that he wasn't. Even when you are a noob you don't want to be called a noob and if you are as experianced as RCT I imagine being called a noob is crossing a very serious line. There is a better way to get a responce and lying and using insults is shady and not constructive. I thought I made my reasons very clear in my post. He lied, manipulated, obfuscated, and had some substantial slips. His responses to those accusations came off as evasive and dishonest. It was by no means an easy descision but I had to listen to my gut.

I'm not exactly sure why you are defending him. To me it's obvious but then I am inexperianced. I agree he shouldn't be voted for no good reason. I do find it suspicious tho. Not FOS or HOS suspiscious but I'll definitly be keeping a closer eye.  

WHo has clammed up around me? THe most active players are ones I've talked to.

You
Padib
ikepor
sparks
Spurge

THe only ones who have clammed up are
White eagle
Hylian (after I accused him)

DO you think it's just coincidental that the people I talk to start talking?
People clam up around me?
You couldn't prove that statement to me even if you had the entire game to do so.

But again, please feel free to bring up each problem you have with me, one by one, and allow me the opportunity to prove you wrong.. because it's easily done. It will just take time.

 

Lastly, again, I don't believe RCT really is convinced I'm mafia.