Mass Effect 2, very closely followed by Battlefield Bad Company 2. On my top 50 of all time games list we made last year on this forum TLOU got #25. I think it was #5 for 7th GEN overall on the same list. I had ME2, BC2, Borderlands 2, and RDR above it and Uncharted 2 was right below it at #26 of all time.
I just could not get into ME2. I was so bored. BC2 was good, but I don't even think it's in the same er "company" as RDR or Borderlands 2. RDR is definitely a top contender, I agree...and I'd agree with Borderlands 2 as well (only if including all dlc).
However, borderlands has a lot of "filler", so I would've ranked it lower.
But, I'm glad, you seem to have good taste. #5 is a very good spot, as is #25 on best of all time. I'd say you don't completely disagree. You jsut disagree a bit. :D