Last of Us at 7 Million according to Twitter! VGC way below

[platformmaster918]

DerNebel said:

platformmaster918 said:

kowenicki said:

maverick40 said:
Could it catch up to Halo 3 which is at 10.5 million once the HD remaster launches?

Amazing for a new IP

...arent you forgetting digital for Halo 3 and MCC?

can we really count if it's in a collection?  How do we know the people bought if for that game?  Do we add numbers to Sonic sales for all the Genesis collections over the years?

If we start using that argument then we start questioning the sales of basically every bundled game ever. Do we know that they bought the bundle for that specific game or did they just buy it because it was the best deal?

We have to be fair here and include those sales as well.

I am fair in that I'm consistent.  I never include the sales of a game that's bundled with every platform.  If a system is readily available without a game bundled with it and people buy the bundle then of course they bought it for that game.  My point about Sonic, GoW (both times), SotC, ICO and many others stands that people never seem to count it towards their sales.  Maybe give each game 1/4 of a sale in a 4 game collection and for GoW Saga each game gets 1/5 of the sales lol