TLOU:R isn't worth it

[DonFerrari]

BMaker11 said:

Zero999 said:

DonFerrari said:

You say your assumptions are basic knowledge, yet no one agrees with you... and I'm certain of seeing several threads of yours with WiiU to sell 15M in one FY and other similar predicitions, how is that a lie? And you are accusing me of derailing my own thread just by saying that you reasoning something against the game is a guarantee that the game will do well? How come?

one year being too soon isn't MY assumption, it's common sense/basic knowledge.

how is this a lie "he never predict anything right by a couple millions margin."? simple, it's not true and you know that while saying it. it had the objective to provoke me and isn't related to the thread, thus the derail.

It's a Game of the Year Edition with updates to compliment the PS4, and it's coming out a year after the original. I think I saw someone earlier in the thread say that people's beef with the game is that it's called "Remastered" instead of "Game of the Year". It's only "Remastered" because it's on the PS4, but other than that, for all intents and purposes, it is "TLOU: GOTY Edition". Do you try this hard to undermine any other GOTY edition of a game? Skyrim? Borderlands? LBP? Batman? Gears 2? All those games have re-releases, a year after the original came out, packed with all the DLC, and sold at a reduced price from standard MSRP. It happens pretty much every year with the biggest games from the prior year. But now a year is too soon...and it being too soon is common knowledge?

I guess instead of:

 

Those respective studios should have had completely new games done, because to release such things only a year after the original? It's common knowledge that it's "too soon" 

Don't forget GOTY editions don't sell 1-2M so people are less worried about them... they don't sell to much HW also.