starcraft said:
The X1 really is not lacking exclusive content this holiday. It has two huge exclusives and one that is likely to be huge just as its headliners. You can reasonably argue they are not for you, or that you don't think they'll sell well. But that doesn't mean the X1's exclusive content isn't very fleshed out for its second holiday! |
The line between lacking content and being "very fleshed out" must be incredibly small if you only need to add a collection to upgrade to the latter 
Personally:
Holiday: X1 > PS4 (X1 slightly less crap than the PS4's).
Overall year: PS4 > X1 (PS4's slightly less crap than the X1's).
Edit: I should add that my opinion of their holiday line ups is within context of the year overall. If they'd both had plenty of proper exclusive releases during the year (or at the very least titles confined to their respective system brand, since cross gen is all the rage) then i'd think both's were decent in themselves. When, however, the holiday line up accounts for every single X1 exclusive released in 2014 that's not on either PC or timed, i consider it disappointing.
The PS4's holiday is even more disappointing, but countered in part by other releases during the year (though not many).
