I'm actually a big fan of misterxmedia. He's just really funny to read.
As far as winning E3 between the console manufacturers, I'd say that it's a statistical tie, which basically means the status quo will remain.
I give Microsoft a lot of credit, though. In my opinion, they typically lose E3 and do something to make them a laughing stock for awhile after, usually centering around Kinect. Not this year.
Nintendo had Zelda, which will get them the most looks, though not all will buy. Still, that attention is an immense positive.
I believe Sony had the single biggest sales impact with Destiny. Most people who want that game came away wanting to play it on a PS4.