Definitely SS. It's OK, but it had several weak points:
-Art style. It was done to mask the weaknesses of the Wii late-gen, and it's not very impressive. Blurring the backgrounds into paintings also breaks immersion.
-Graphics. Not breath-taking. Zelda should be a visual stunner.
-Motion controls. It's fine for a sword as long as you're not using the dongle, but for throwing bombs or flapping a birds wings it's just tiresome.
-Reused features. Characters, side quests and other aspects are pulled straight from other titles. Especially Wind Waker.
-Hand holding. Please let me try to solve a puzzle at least before telling me what to do.
-Dorky look of the birds. They could have been so bad ass too...
-Ugly Zelda.
-Weak-ish story. It had some real strong points, but also some overall weaknesses. It could have been fleshed out more. Like the giant bad-ass flying thing - that should have been terrorizing the whole game until you face it, rather than just coming out of no where.
Overall it just didn't seem ground-breaking like almost every other Zelda title. OK, but not on par with the others.
