So, looks like I'm getting an XBO sooner rather than later.

[Wright]

Adinnieken said:

Why?

The problem with Halo: Reach isn't the story, it's where in the line of games it ended up.  Had Reach been the first game, rather than at the end of the trilogy, it wouldn't have been so bad.  Granted, it would have been better if it had been more like H:CE.

I liked Reach.  Even though the story was considerably different from the book, I still liked the story.  I would say I enjoyed Halo: Reach more than almost any other Halo game other the H:CE.

I found plot holes, lack of attachment to the characters at all and an overall sense of disappointment playing Reach. This is not an objetive analysis, but rather my own personal experience with the game. I don't say the game is bad as a fact, but how I felt with it.