Why does Watch Dogs help PS4 but do nothing for XB1

[Nicklesbe]

dane007 said:

Nicklesbe said:

That is a flat out lie and contradictory. You cannot say one minute "yes I noticed all these differences" and then say another minute that there are no noticeable difference. It's not true quit saying. Quit bringing up DF, anything he said is completely hearsay and is completely outside of your or my experiences. Unlike you I've seen it in side by side on ps4, Xb1 and ps3. The quality of the audio is not the same, the quality of the textures is not the same. It is not possible to display textures in 720p with the same quality as 900p. Yes there are more frequent fps drops in the ps3 version but they still occur in the Xb1 version. Tearing can be just as frequent at times. I've seen it myself so you can keep spouting the same unfounded nonsense over and over and contradicting yourself and just plain ignoring reality but none of it holds true.

maybe i worded it wrong. I was trying to say that in terms of lighting, texture, physics , water  quality and draw distance are identical with no differene. the only difference would be screen tearing whihc happens a bit more  on xbox one.  my experience with it is exactly as mentioned above ,, the only difference is i could dbealy notice screen tearing ,, especially frequency of it. they di dhappen but to say one occurs moe then the other is hard to spot. Hence why i beleive df analyss as they are the experts in the analysis area. I know theres a resolution difference but on my 55inch tv ,, i couldn't see the difference. to be honest ,, if i didn't know about teh resolution difference,, i wouldn't be able to tell which is ps4 version and which is XO version. The audio not the same? do elaborate on that since DF never mentioned yet.  and ps3 is so bad that it flatlines at constant 20fps with anything  elseremoved to make it run on last gen specs. DF specifically said that and i know for sure XO doe not run at a  constant 20fps with absurd screen tearing as mentioned in the DF report. i hoep i made my explanation cleare. sorry fo rthe misunderstandings

They aren't identical tho. Not even close. It's not possible. Try standing closer to your TV or get larger than 55 inch. If you do you will notice the real disparity in texture quality. As far as audio goes both the Xb1 and ps3 audio is more compressed, which is noticeable if you have two TV's right next to each other. If you really want to hear the difference i suggest investing in some high quality headphones like a Bose Quietcomfort. You will hear a noticeable difference. It doesn't matter what DF said according to you you saw PS4 and Xb1 side by side. If you really did then surly you would have seen and heard a real difference. I'm starting to think you never actually have since your own reference point seems to be what DF said and your own personal experiences are contradictory and at times simply not possible. I've seen Xb1 drop to 15-20 fps  in areas with lots of enemy gun fire with 20+ enemies and sometimes during digital trips and right after some online multiplayer games end. Like races or being killed by someone you are tailing/hacking. I wouldn't call you being deceptive, contradictory, and putting your foot repeatedly in your mouth a misunderstanding but to each their own.