No, it wouldn't
It would've been forgotten quicker than Beyond.
NOBODY talks about Beyond.
If Ryse was made by QD which would also make it exclusive to Playstation, we would all talk about how this game is a perfect example of how Playstation fans overhype their games, how Sony game are just GRAPHIC GRAPHICS GRAPHICS with crappy gameplay, and the users who seem to praise it today would probably be singing a different tune about it if it was a PS game.
Also i'm replaying through The Last Of Us now and that gameplay is GREAT. That gameplay was VERY fluid. That gameplay was about as good as a survival horror game gets. theres probably only a couple things to improve on going forward. So i don't know what you're trying to go off on by claiming that the gameplay is average
