If Sony made the Wii and Nintendo made a PS3. How would last gen have played out?

[Pyro as Bill]

dharh said:

Pyro as Bill said:

Serious question.

Power and price being equal.

I daresay X360 would have won the war.

The Wii itself, not necessarily Nintendo is why I disliked the Wii. I have almost no interest in 1st party games from either camp. A SONY Wii, a horribly underpowered console, with clunky (imo) motion controls as the primary input device. Third party multi-plat RPGs, the games that I buy, would be inferior to the versions on the X360. So I would not have bought heavily into a SONY Wii.

Likewise a Nintendo PS3 (sic) would probably have had the same problems the Nintendo Wii did. Almost zero RPGs. The Wii had Xenoblade chronicles, really what else? I doubt they would have had much more given Nintendos track record with 3rd party studios. Lack of good 3rd party RPGs, a complete lack of synergy with how Nintendo does things. So I would not have bought heavily into a Nintendo PS3. 

Thus the choice would have been largly in X360s favor by default.

Keep in mind I ended up owning all three consoles. My PS3 library is significantly greater than the other two though.

As an owner of all 3, what % crossover do you think there was last gen?