It took me a while to think of one, but then I remembered God of War. I thought it looked whatever but everyone said it was great, so some years ago I finally tried out the first one. I thought it was okay, though a little boring. I was interested enough to play for a few hours, but then not interested enough to pick it up again afterward. Just not my kind of game, I guess. Hacking and slashing just gets old.
Currently playing:
Bloodbath Paddy Wagon Ultra 9