blaydcor said:
kingofwale said:
No one is saying this game deserves a 5.. or even a 4, but give it 2 while other game who had the same problem received much higher rating? That itself is what pissed people off.
Is Crisis Core perfect? Well no, but does it deserve 40% rating? Well, no.
I have no doubt Adam came to that conclusion after viewing 4 dialogues, that's because he NEVER PLAYED the game himself. taking them out of content by quoting pieces of it for the sake of bashing it can very easily be done. You can do that with any speech, but if you actually play the game (like Adam should've done), he'd realize it wasn't that horrible, and some of the poetry references are quite witty. |
This is what Bodesahtva can'd understand; we arent' saying that his complaints dont' have some legitimacy to them (yes, the dialogue is kinda hammy, and yes, early on you could get away with X-mashing, if you're boring and uncreative), but that Adam gives them far too much attention, and that they should definitely not drop a solid game's score to a FOUR. It's just ridiculous. I've played games that deserve 4's, and this is far from that.
|
No, I do understand this. That is, in fact, stated implicitly in the first sentence of my first post in this entire thread.
You agree that X-play's complaints have legitimacy? Okay, good. We agree then. We're done. I'll restate the first sentence of my first post again: No one seems to be making any criticisms of his actual review, where he gave reasons for this score.
