Comparing the legacy of the WiiU Gamepad and XOne Kinect 2.0 -- which is worse?

[fleischr]

kowenicki said:

Being objective...

One can be removed and therefore doesn't seal its consoles fate in the longer term, the other cant and therefore does seal its consoles fate in the longer term. Thus the gamepad legacy is far, far worse as its continued inclusion renders the WiiU a probably failure forever. The One can continue without (or with for those that still want it)

 

But the poll here will have an obvious conclusion...

Agreed to some extent. A gamepad-less WiiU is just an Xbox 360 with Nintendo games, but fewer games overall.

Taking sales out of consideration though, and looking at it purely from a gameplay aspect -- Kinect is far worse.