mysteryman said:
1) You are denying the antecedent. A game which has several entries selling over 9 million copies has broad appeal. If one entry fails to sell well, this does not prove the opposite. You are not considering other potential factors. If it rains, then the grass gets wet. 1ii) Yep, it's pretty scary going to the shops and having the cashier put a gun to your head until you've bought your quota of 1st party Nintendo titles for the day. I've already discussed the options available for racing games, and even kart racers on Nintendo's systems. Mario Kart just sells better. 2) Right back to denying the antecedent. By this logic, all XBOX Original titles had zero mass appeal, as it sold similar to the GC. But you have denied this conclusion, as it somehow only applies to Nintendo systems. Your logic is completely flawed. |
Now you are making leaps of logic.
You've completely ignored what I said about Nintendo not giving their customers the option to shop around for other titles in the same genre and instead have decided to be immature about it. Not cool dude. When you say broad appeal, what you actually mean is "lack of competition & choice". Also, define "broad appeal". I'm talking about the entire Nintendo ecosystem and beyond. You seem to be just looking at sales figures. When Nintendo needs to reach out to a large market, sales suggest it is just reaching out to the same people with every 1st party title they release This cannot be said of Call of Duty and Forza. It is likely that the two games appeal to two different markets. Nintendo games (and this is my main point) appeals to just one market - existing Nintendo fans. Nintendo third party offerings tend to be shovelware. Want to argue differently? Then explain the poor sales of 3rd party titles *oh snap*.
Don't worry though, I'll have even more proof of Nintendo fans buying only Nintendo games when MK is released as I can guarentee the uptake will be very high, but the console still won't sell well.