Help me choose: Pikmin 3 or Wind Waker

[d21lewis]

Metallox said:

Metrium said:
Wind Waker w/o a doubt. Pikmin 3 is really fun, it's a good game but it's a incomplete game. It's way to short and has a more than lackluster ending showing under the spotlight how incomplete and to short this game is.

Wind Waker on the other hand is a epic 15hours+ adventure in a open world vs a game that lasts for about 8hours tops that is made of small lvl after small lvls.

Hahaha You really don't know Pikmin 3's issues. It's not only what you mentioned. I'll list all my problems with Pikmin 3:

-No control scheme is good, playing with Wiimote is good but is horrible for flying enemies. Otherwise, using the Gamepad makes the pointer slower, and in Pikmin, that's just wasted time. 

-Rock Pikmin don't respond after they hit something. I just hate that.

-Lacks content. Less areas, same enemies from previous games... you don't really know how disappointed I am in that aspect.

-Ground textures are AWFUL.

-No caves.

-Worst Final Boss Ever.

 

At least its Mission Mode it's amazing, it's just too addictive. BY THE WAY, I'm actually surprised that many people prefer Pikmin 3 over Wind Waker, you know, because it's Zelda.

I though the Wii Remote/Nunchuck combo worked flawlessly.  I just kept the Gamepad sitting off to the side in case I needed the map or to automaitcally send someone somewhere.  Aside from that, I didn't really notice any of the other issues you had.  I agree it was over too soon, though.