By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
mai said:
Kasz216 said:

Not sure why you think any of your points actually prove your point, their isn't anything TO refute.

Are you answering to your inner voice or what? Have you actually addressed any of my points? Should I repeat them for a third time -- people with red armbands, police with same armbands, both nothing to do with people who have been slaughtered?

Kasz216 said:

As for grain taken... I'm not sure how much more terminologically correct I could be... but sure...

The soviets took food from the Ukraine during the famine, blacklisted villigaes that couldn't produce enough, basically causing them to die, and a whole other list of henious shit. 

Quote actual act goddammit, are we talking about "food assessment" or what? Be precise.


Oh I mean nothing to refute on the holomodor thing.  This stuff is just something i'm not inclined to dig into due to your general lack of reliability whe it comes to these conspiracy theory like angles as shown when you were completely wrong on the Yakymenko statements, not even knowing when he assumed power.

 

As for the actual act... with the grain,  do I speak russian?   It's exports after what would closest translate to "Food Requistion" i'd guess.   I'm doing this from memory.

It's not like it's some rare unknown policy or anything.  The tax was something like 40% of expected totals, with yields inflated to the point of where, basically farmers couldn't pay their shit, villiages got blacklisted, and then were basically fucked.

Of course, you really haven't addressed why they'd keep a famine top secret for 50 years punishable by prison time if it was mentioned... or blacklisting or any of that.